Comments on: 10 Questions to See If Your Social media “GURU” is Up to Speed http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/ Web site Coaching, Editor of The Web Coach INSIDER & Get Clients NOW! Facilitator Mon, 21 Sep 2009 22:21:50 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.com/ By: Donna Payne http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/#comment-178 Donna Payne Tue, 28 Jul 2009 19:05:24 +0000 http://donnapayne.com/?p=370#comment-178 Welcome Ian, so glad to hear from you! I love your mind - truly a brilliant man. Most of the time, 8 out of 10 I'd say, I usually include the first 5 or 6 sentences, or paragraph as a teaser. Your post was different because I wanted my readers to really feel your humor up front and see what kinds of questions you'd ask. As you know, many newbies don't even know what to ask or look for, which is who most of my target market is. Trust me when I tell you, I'm VERY particular about copy and originality. I once had a client who swiped word-for-word another's web copy, only to call me at 11:30pm in a frenzied panic to take down her website because she had been busted by the original copy owner. Boy, talk about foolish! Thanks for the tip on smaller bits w/commentary. You've inspired an article in the works. Best to you, dp Welcome Ian, so glad to hear from you! I love your mind – truly a brilliant man.

Most of the time, 8 out of 10 I’d say, I usually include the first 5 or 6 sentences, or paragraph as a teaser.

Your post was different because I wanted my readers to really feel your humor up front and see what kinds of questions you’d ask.

As you know, many newbies don’t even know what to ask or look for, which is who most of my target market is.

Trust me when I tell you, I’m VERY particular about copy and originality. I once had a client who swiped word-for-word another’s web copy, only to call me at 11:30pm in a frenzied panic to take down her website because she had been busted by the original copy owner. Boy, talk about foolish!

Thanks for the tip on smaller bits w/commentary. You’ve inspired an article in the works.

Best to you, dp

]]>
By: Ian Lurie http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/#comment-177 Ian Lurie Tue, 28 Jul 2009 04:28:42 +0000 http://donnapayne.com/?p=370#comment-177 I feel like I should weigh in here. I'm a particularly strong opponent of any form of scraping or plagiarism. I've spoken out, and called people out, in no uncertain terms for stealing my work. It pisses me off. But what Donna's done here is OK. Yes, she copied a fair amount of my article, but calls it out as such, and provides several 'dofollowed' links back to my blog. The only thing I might do different: Instead of excerpting one big chunk, I'd excerpt several smaller ones with commentary in between. That would get you more search engine leverage as your content would have a better chance of being considered unique. I feel like I should weigh in here. I’m a particularly strong opponent of any form of scraping or plagiarism. I’ve spoken out, and called people out, in no uncertain terms for stealing my work. It pisses me off.

But what Donna’s done here is OK. Yes, she copied a fair amount of my article, but calls it out as such, and provides several ‘dofollowed’ links back to my blog.

The only thing I might do different: Instead of excerpting one big chunk, I’d excerpt several smaller ones with commentary in between. That would get you more search engine leverage as your content would have a better chance of being considered unique.

]]>
By: Donna Payne http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/#comment-174 Donna Payne Sun, 26 Jul 2009 17:52:30 +0000 http://donnapayne.com/?p=370#comment-174 Parasite? Search engine rankings? Benefiting from his post? Ha! LOL! Funny how the ignorant mind works. Go clutter up someone else's blog with your rhetoric - I don't waste energy or time on anonymous "evangelists" like you. Parasite? Search engine rankings? Benefiting from his post? Ha! LOL! Funny how the ignorant mind works.

Go clutter up someone else’s blog with your rhetoric – I don’t waste energy or time on anonymous “evangelists” like you.

]]>
By: SNiffer http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/#comment-173 SNiffer Sun, 26 Jul 2009 17:38:20 +0000 http://donnapayne.com/?p=370#comment-173 You are a "parasitic aggregator" - take a listen to NPR's On the Media interview this morning with 1st amendment lawyer David Marberger. That's his name for people like you. I predict he will succeed in his quest to get the copyright act changed and shut down parasites like you. You need to be stopped from benefiting from re-posting the content of real original content producers. Admit it (if you can even be honest with yourself), you could just as easily post a simple link to his content, instead of copying and pasting it in whole onto your own site. You've set yourself up to compete with him for search engine rankings for his content. Not nice. http://www.onthemedia.org/transcripts/2009/07/24/05 You are a “parasitic aggregator” – take a listen to NPR’s On the Media interview this morning with 1st amendment lawyer David Marberger. That’s his name for people like you.

I predict he will succeed in his quest to get the copyright act changed and shut down parasites like you. You need to be stopped from benefiting from re-posting the content of real original content producers.

Admit it (if you can even be honest with yourself), you could just as easily post a simple link to his content, instead of copying and pasting it in whole onto your own site. You’ve set yourself up to compete with him for search engine rankings for his content. Not nice.

http://www.onthemedia.org/transcripts/2009/07/24/05

]]>
By: Donna Payne http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/#comment-172 Donna Payne Sun, 26 Jul 2009 16:19:07 +0000 http://donnapayne.com/?p=370#comment-172 I am not "re-hashing" Ian's content. If anything I'm driving more readers to his blog, and adding VALUE to my own subscribers by exposing them to his brilliant writings in an excerpt. In addition, this post was added to Friendfeed, Twitter and Facebook. People need to SHARE information - that's what social media is! Sheesh! Get over yourself. Also, if you Google "web coach tip" you'll see that MY articles are posted in over 730k locations online. I'm hardly "scraping" anybody else's content. BTW, "sniffer"... funny how your domain is just a parked go daddy account with no real way of contacting you. I'll just assume you are an intern on a pointless crusade. ps. You spelled copyrighted wrong. Duh! I am not “re-hashing” Ian’s content. If anything I’m driving more readers to his blog, and adding VALUE to my own subscribers by exposing them to his brilliant writings in an excerpt.

In addition, this post was added to Friendfeed, Twitter and Facebook. People need to SHARE information – that’s what social media is! Sheesh! Get over yourself.

Also, if you Google “web coach tip” you’ll see that MY articles are posted in over 730k locations online. I’m hardly “scraping” anybody else’s content.

BTW, “sniffer”… funny how your domain is just a parked go daddy account with no real way of contacting you.

I’ll just assume you are an intern on a pointless crusade.

ps. You spelled copyrighted wrong. Duh!

]]>
By: SNiffer http://donnapayne.com/2009/07/25/10-questions-to-evaluate-a-social-media-guru/#comment-171 SNiffer Sun, 26 Jul 2009 15:56:01 +0000 http://donnapayne.com/?p=370#comment-171 Why do you use other people's original copywrighted content and basically re-hash it then twitter it as if it were your own? Dishonest. You should just link to the original article. You have added no value, you have simply scraped content. Why do you use other people’s original copywrighted content and basically re-hash it then twitter it as if it were your own? Dishonest. You should just link to the original article. You have added no value, you have simply scraped content.

]]>